OK, I thought I was done with this topic--I've written three previous posts on this. But then I received another email from our friends at ________ advertising their subscription sermon series. Just when I think they've hit bottom, well, they prove me wrong. Now they are selling "award winning" sermons preached at some of the largest churches in America. Is that a fact?
Rather than tackle the question of plagiarism and sloth (I've already covered that ground), this time I will focus upon the sermon topics they are pitching. Pretty bad . . .
The latest email begins with the prompt "this Sunday will be a time when pastors will be preparing people's hearts for THANKSGIVING." Oh, is that so? As a minister of word and sacrament, my job is to preach Christ crucified, not get people ready to celebrate a national holiday--although, at Christ Reformed we do hold a worship service on Thanksgiving in which we devote the bulk of our time to actually giving thanks.
Next comes the sales pitch. "If you would like to subscribe today we would like to send you the thanksgiving sermon, `WHERE ARE THE NINE' free." In light of the earlier sermon we discussed (Click here: Riddleblog - The Latest Post - On Subscription Sermon Series (Part 1), I'll bet this one is a doozy!
Here's the "set" of sermons they are selling. It includes the following titles:
(1) Two Great Women (Mother's Day)
(2) Bogus Resolutions (New Years)
(3) How God's Plans Interfere With Our Plans (Christmas)
(4) Where Do We Find Comfort? (Friend's Day)
(5) The Proofs of The Resurrection (Easter)
(6) The Excitement of Easter (Easter)
(7) Funeral Service #1
(8) Funeral Service #2
(9) Grandparent's Day
(10) Heaven (Funeral)
(11) Mother's Day 2001
(12) Excellent Role Models (Youth or Father's Day)
(13) Kodak Moments In The Life Of Christ (Christmas)
(14) What We Should Be Thankful For (Thanksgiving)
(15) Where Are The Nine? (Thanksgiving)
(16) What We Can Learn From The Past (New Years)
Since I've never preached a sermon on Grandparent's Day--sorry, but I don't follow the Hallmark calendar--I have no idea what this would entail. I am curious, "will the Mother's Day sermon from 2001 work in 2008?" I'll bet the sermon on comfort (Friend's Day) has nothing to do with guilt-grace-gratitude, and while evidence for the resurrection sounds good, I'm not sure "excitement" is a term I'd use for Easter. Kodak Moments for Christmas? Role models for Father's Day?
As an expository preacher who works from a biblical text, I'm not a fan of topical sermons--especially when they are based on the Hallmark calendar.
Here's the final pitch: "All sixteen of these sermons are award winning sermons that have been preached in many of the largest churches in the United States."
I'm a bit of a cynic. So, my question is, "who determines whether a sermon receives an award?" Furthermore, given the claim that these sermons are supposedly used in many of the largest churches in America, this begs the question as to whether the pastors of these churches are using this subscription sermon series and passing someone else's material off as their own. But could it be that this particular subscription series is based upon sermons taken from these large churches and then sold as part of their package deal?
Either way, this is real trouble. Preachers are preaching sermons they did not write, and these topical sermons (if they are like our previous example) fall far short of the public placarding of Christ, called for by the apostle Paul (Galatians 3:1).